'all those of' and 'those of all'

[weihe0904]

Results from the 1998 National Demographic and Health Survey confirm that, even when compared with densely populated countries like Thailand and Indonesia, the Philippine nation's fertility rates consistently exceed all of its Southeast Asian neighbors.

(A) like Thailand and Indonesia, the Philippine nation's fertility rates consistently exceed all of
(B) like Thailand and Indonesia, the Philippine nation consistently exhibits fertility rates exceeding all
(C) such as Thailand and Indonesia, the fertility rates exhibited by the Philippine nation are consistently exceeding those of all
(D) such as Thailand and Indonesia, the Philippine nation's fertility rates consistently exceed all those of
(E) such as Thailand and Indonesia, the Philippine nation consistently exhibits fertility rates that exceed those of all

could anyone pls explain why E is correct? I chose D. I cannot really figure out the difference between 'all those of' and 'those of all', pls help.

thanks!

[weihe0904]

Ok, I just realized why (D) is wrong, (D) compares coutries to fertility rate.

[mikrodj]

I think the difference is

all those of ---> each Southeast Asian neighbor has many fertility rates
those of all ---> each Southeast Asian neighbor has one fertility rate

[RonPurewal]

Ok, I just realized why (D) is wrong, (D) compares coutries to fertility rate.

yeah. this is a baseline error - you must train yourself to look for PARALLEL COMPARISONS.

choice (d) contains
even when compared with densely populated countries such as Thailand and Indonesia, the Philippine nation's fertility rates

that's not a valid comparison. since the non-underlined parts of the comparison are countries, the underlined item has to be a country, too.

[RonPurewal]

I think the difference is

all those of ---> each Southeast Asian neighbor has many fertility rates
those of all ---> each Southeast Asian neighbor has one fertility rate

this is accurate. well done.