by esledge Thu Jun 24, 2021 7:01 pm
If I saw this one today, I'd still ask "what is lower?" and the options are the costs or the amount they rose (2.8 percent) or maybe even September? There's ambiguity: if costs are lower, that conflicts with the idea that they already rose. But to convey the idea that 2.8 percent is relatively low, something is missing: I'd want to add a noun to complete and clarify the comparison, such as "rose 2.8 percent in the 12 months..., lower than the percentage in the year that ended." It rose X percent this time, lower than the percentage (or the increase) another time.
So even if less vs. lower is too close to call meaning-wise, the choices have another difference: the clauses in choices A,B,C, and E, where the pronoun and verbs clarify the intended meaning and complete the parallel structure (or fail to...). For that reason, I think this question would be at home on the current test.
Emily Sledge
Instructor
ManhattanGMAT