Verbal question you found somewhere else? General issue with idioms or grammar? Random verbal question? These questions belong here.
suri_c
 
 

Idioms

by suri_c Sat Sep 06, 2008 4:34 pm

could you please tell me why these sentences are wrong?

1. Resulting from his effort, the company grew.
2. While in childhood, i played baseball.
3. With only 10% of the vote, the party did not win the election.
4. Grass grew fast because of the sun shining.
5. A rising of prices at the gas pump is making me nervous.
vscid
 
 

by vscid Tue Sep 09, 2008 11:48 pm

1. Resulting from his effort, the company grew. - 'RESULTING FROM' is unidiomatic. Should be 'As a result of '
2. While in childhood, i played baseball. - While in childhood' is unidiomatic.
3. With only 10% of the vote, the party did not win the election. - dont know why this's wrong. (Please comment Stacy)
4. Grass grew fast because of the sun shining. - better to use 'shining sun'
5. A rising of prices at the gas pump is making me nervous. - 'rise of prices' is better.
esledge
Forum Guests
 
Posts: 1181
Joined: Tue Mar 01, 2005 6:33 am
Location: St. Louis, MO
 

Idioms and Subordinate Clauses

by esledge Mon Oct 13, 2008 12:40 am

1. I agree with vscid: As a result of his effort, the company grew.

2. As a child, I played baseball.

3. "with" is a prepositional phase, so ask yourself what it modifies. Either "The party (with only 10% of the vote) did not win" or "The party did not win (with only 10% of the vote)." The latter is terrible, and the ambiguity in general is to be avoided. I think "Receiving only 10% of the vote, the party did not win" would work, as the modifier clearly modifies the party.

4. The adverb "quickly" is required to modify "grew" instead of the adjective "fast." I agree with vscid: "shining sun" is preferable to "sun shining." In English, we tend to put the adjective first, noun second. For example, "brick" is a noun, "house" is a noun, but when we talk about a "brick house," brick now plays the role of modifier: what kind of house? In your sentence, if the sun made the grass grow, we should use the modified noun "shining sun." If you mean that "the shining" was what caused the grass to grow, then say that: "Grass grew quickly because of the shining of the sun."

5. The increase in prices at the gas pump is making me nervous. (this would be better than "the rise of prices")
Emily Sledge
Instructor
ManhattanGMAT