Q20

 
cew
Thanks Received: 0
Vinny Gambini
Vinny Gambini
 
Posts: 2
Joined: January 27th, 2014
 
 
 

Q20

by cew Sat Jul 05, 2014 8:47 pm

I felt dissatisfied with the answer choices for question 20. I easily eliminated A, D, and E as unsupported, but then struggled to choose between B and C.

(B) Wholly unregulated economies are probably the fastest in producing an equalization of social status.

(C) Expanded access to printed texts across a population has historically led to an increase in literacy in that population.

I did end up choosing C, because it felt like the smaller leap, (B is quite a big leap!) but both felt like leaps to me. I found the support for the inference in C in lines 18-22:

"Since printed materials have become widely available, however, people without special position or resources--and in numbers once thought impossible--can take literacy and the use of printed texts for granted."

What makes this an acceptable inference? That people can take literacy for granted once they have widely available printed materials? There seems to me to be a big gap here. (But maybe I'm really just attacking the passage's argument instead of interpreting it...)
User avatar
 
uhdang
Thanks Received: 25
Atticus Finch
Atticus Finch
 
Posts: 227
Joined: March 05th, 2015
 
 
 

Re: Q20

by uhdang Tue May 12, 2015 11:41 pm

cew Wrote:I felt dissatisfied with the answer choices for question 20. I easily eliminated A, D, and E as unsupported, but then struggled to choose between B and C.

(B) Wholly unregulated economies are probably the fastest in producing an equalization of social status.

(C) Expanded access to printed texts across a population has historically led to an increase in literacy in that population.

I did end up choosing C, because it felt like the smaller leap, (B is quite a big leap!) but both felt like leaps to me. I found the support for the inference in C in lines 18-22:

"Since printed materials have become widely available, however, people without special position or resources--and in numbers once thought impossible--can take literacy and the use of printed texts for granted."

What makes this an acceptable inference? That people can take literacy for granted once they have widely available printed materials? There seems to me to be a big gap here. (But maybe I'm really just attacking the passage's argument instead of interpreting it...)


I think C) is more or lass paraphrasing the line 18-22.
"Fun"